Manchester United’s summer transfer window is already shaping up to be one of the most intriguing among Europe’s top clubs, and one player at the centre of speculation is Brazilian winger Antony. The 24-year-old, signed with much fanfare from Ajax in 2022 for a fee that could rise to €100 million, has yet to fully justify that hefty price tag. Now, United have reportedly set a €58 million asking price for the winger, with multiple clubs — including Newcastle United, Brighton & Hove Albion, Bayer Leverkusen and RB Leipzig — monitoring the situation closely.
For United, this potential sale is about more than just moving on from a player who has struggled for consistency. It’s about recalibrating the squad to fit new manager Erik ten Hag’s evolving vision — assuming he remains at the helm — and ensuring the club remains within the confines of the Premier League’s Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR). United’s spending over the last few windows has been significant, yet results on the pitch have been mixed at best.
Antony’s time at Old Trafford has been tumultuous. Signed by Ten Hag, who knew him well from their time together at Ajax, Antony was expected to bring flair, directness, and a touch of Brazilian magic to United’s right flank. While there have been flashes of brilliance — including important goals in Europe and some standout performances in domestic cups — his overall output has been underwhelming. He has struggled with the physicality of the Premier League and has often been criticised for lacking end product.
The €58 million price tag is interesting for two reasons: first, it represents a significant loss on United’s original investment; second, it suggests the club believes there is still a market for Antony’s talent, despite his struggles in England. Indeed, the list of suitors shows there is no shortage of belief in his potential.
Newcastle United’s interest makes sense. The Magpies are looking to add creativity and depth to their attack as they continue to build a squad capable of challenging for the top four on a regular basis. With Champions League or Europa League football on the horizon again, adding a technically gifted wide player like Antony could complement their more direct attacking options like Anthony Gordon and Alexander Isak.
Brighton & Hove Albion’s involvement is also no surprise. Under Roberto De Zerbi, the Seagulls have developed a reputation for giving flair players the freedom to express themselves. Brighton’s recruitment team has excelled at spotting undervalued or underperforming talent and reviving careers. Antony could see a move to Brighton as an opportunity to rediscover his form in a system that might suit his style better than the rigid structures at Old Trafford.
Bayer Leverkusen and RB Leipzig, meanwhile, represent two of Germany’s most forward-thinking clubs. Leverkusen, under Xabi Alonso, won the Bundesliga in remarkable fashion last season and are set for another Champions League campaign. They are reportedly bracing for interest in some of their stars, so they may see Antony as a readymade replacement for any outgoing wingers. Leipzig, famous for their high-energy, pressing football, are always on the lookout for young, talented attackers who can be developed and sold on for profit. A move to the Bundesliga could help Antony regain confidence away from the intense glare of the English media.
From the player’s perspective, a fresh start might be exactly what he needs. His confidence at United has clearly suffered, and the fanbase has been unforgiving of his inconsistency. A new environment — whether in England or abroad — could help him rediscover the fearless approach that made him such a sensation at Ajax.
For United, the key question is whether they can find a club willing to meet their €58 million valuation. While Newcastle could afford such a fee, Brighton’s record signing is still below that figure, and Bundesliga clubs are rarely willing to spend that heavily without guaranteed resale value. United may find themselves negotiating a lower fee or agreeing to a structured deal with add-ons.
Ultimately, Antony’s situation is emblematic of United’s bigger transfer problem: buying high and selling low. If they do offload Antony this summer, it will be another reminder that their recruitment strategy in recent years has too often been reactive rather than proactive. However, if they can use the funds wisely to strengthen priority areas — such as central midfield, a new striker, or defensive reinforcements — it could be a step in the right direction.
One thing is clear: Antony’s next move will be decisive for his career. At 24, he still has time to fulfil the promise that made United bet big on him two years ago. Whether he does so in the Premier League, the Bundesliga or elsewhere could be one of the more fascinating stories of this summ
er’s transfer window.
